Cyber Bill: CSOs plead with Mudenda for more public consultations
About seven civil society organisations have written to Speaker of the National Assembly Jacob Mudenda pleading for another round of public consultation on the Cybersecurity and Data Protection Bill which was recently recommitted to the Senate.
The Bill was recommitted back to the Committee Stage in the Senate due to various errors that were discovered.
In the letter written by Misa Zimbabwe chairperson Golden Maunganidze which was endorsed by Content Creators Network of Zimbabwe, Media Alliance of Zimbabwe, Zimbabwe Online Content Creators, Zimbabwe NGO Forum, Zimbabwe Human Rights Association and Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human Rights, the CSOs contend that the errors show the Bill needs more fine-tuning.
Below are the full details of the letter that was written to Mudenda by the CSOs:
MISA Zimbabwe by virtue of this letter, together with the undersigned organisations, writes to you to humbly highlight and express our concerns on developments arising from the recommittal of the Cybersecurity and Data Protection Bill to the Senate.
It is our humble submission that this development is undoubtedly of national significance and interest which deserves your esteemed attention and all the necessary due processes in line with the constitutional role and obligations of the Parliament of Zimbabwe.
The Cyber Security and Data Protection Bill which was gazetted in May 2020 and subjected to public hearings in July 2020, has now been recommitted in Senate following its passing in the National Assembly.
This recommittal is a clear indication that there are significant errors that have been noted necessitating substantive amendments to the Bill.
In light of the above, we, the undersigned organisations, hereby petition Parliament and the Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Information Communication Technology, Postal and Courier Services to subject the amended Bill to public hearings.
CSO’s position on Cyber Bill
Our position, through this petition for purposes of fostering and entrenching Zimbabwe’s constitutional democracy, is informed by the following reasons:
- Section 141 of the Constitution stipulates that Parliament must facilitate public involvement in its legislative and other processes and in the processes of its committees.
- In addition, Parliament should ensure interested parties are consulted about Bills being considered by Parliament unless such consultation is inappropriate or impracticable.
- The Cybersecurity and Data Protection Bill has clearly been subjected to significant changes and varied substantively from the gazetted Bill that was subject to public hearings.
- Passing this Bill into law, in its amended form without public consultation on the various changes is tantamount to violating the constitutional rights of citizens to participate and influence the law-making process.
- In light of the errors of a material nature that have been noted and acknowledged by the Senate, there is a need for an extensive review of the Bill with further input from the general public as well.
- To act and proceed otherwise, would be tantamount to Parliament undermining its duty to consult the public on key legislative developments.
- A law that addresses issues relating to cybersecurity, data protection and data privacy, affects every citizen, hence the need for a multi-stakeholder approach in its framing.
- Following the public hearings in July 2020, a Parliamentary Committee report was produced, which proposed recommendations as collected and compiled from the public consultations carried out.
- These recommendations should have informed and guided the changes made to this Bill. If significant changes outside the proposed recommendations have been further made, resulting in the substantive deviation from the original Bill, it is only reasonable, necessary and justifiable that the Bill, in its current state, be subjected to public hearings.
We are therefore appealing to you Honourable Speaker, the Clerk of Parliament, and Chairperson of the Parliamentary Committee on Information and Communication Technology, Courier and Postal Services, by virtue of the authority vested in you, to again subject the Bill to scrutiny by the people in the spirit of promoting, respecting and upholding the tenets of democracy.
The Cyber Security and Data Protection Bill is a key piece of legislation as it impacts the social, political and economic landscape of Zimbabwe.
A strong cybersecurity and data protection framework is critical for the exercise and enjoyment of human rights, trade, increased investments and Zimbabwe’s socio-economic development.
Thank you for your kind consideration.
Golden Maunganidze
Chairperson
Cyber Bill: CSOs plead with Mudenda for more public consultations
